ANONYMOUS 16TH CENTURY (FORMERLY ATTRIBUTED TO NICOLAS BEATRIZET) AFTER MICHELANGELO BUONARROTI (1475-1564)
The Dream (Il Sogno)
Important information about this lot
Price Realised GBP 6,250
Estimate
GBP 1,500 - GBP 2,500
Estimates do not reflect the final hammer price and do not include buyer's premium, any applicable taxes or artist's resale right. Please see the Conditions of Sale for full details.
Loading details
Try our
ANONYMOUS 16TH CENTURY (FORMERLY ATTRIBUTED TO NICOLAS BEATRIZET) AFTER MICHELANGELO BUONARROTI (1475-1564)
This enigmatic and diaphanous composition, on which the present engraving is based, was drawn in black chalk by Michelangelo around 1533. It is probably one of the presentation drawings given by the artist to the object of his passionate and enduring love, the young Roman nobleman Tommaso de' Cavalieri. The rather vague common title Il Sogno(‘The Dream’) was given to the drawing by Vasari in 1568, but it’s meaning has been the subject of discussion for centuries. Today, Erwin Panofsky’s interpretation of this composition as a moral allegory of the human soul, awakened from vice to virtue, appears to be generally accepted.
At the centre of the composition is a half-reclining male nude, in his pose not unlike that of Adam in the vault of the Sistine Chapel and also of Lazarus being raised from the grave. The figure is awakened by an winged genius or angel with a trumpet hovering in the air above him. He sits on a box, open at the front and revealing a collection of theatrical masks. In a position that is highly unstable, he rests with his arms and side against a sphere.
In the background is a multitude of interlaced figures, surrounding the central figure in a semi-circular ‘halo’: amorous couples, a drinker, a figure roasting a goose, and a couple of disembodied phalluses at left; several fighting figures, a crouching man, and two hands holding a money bag (a detail not without sexual innuendo either) at right. These figments of the dreamer’s imagination presumably represent the deadly sins, while the masks in the box are symbols of worldly illusion and deception. The sphere can undoubtedly be read as a metaphor for the uncertainty and fragility of human life.
According to Michael Bury (2010) 'a variety of different engravers, working for different publishers and probably (...) motivated by different objectives, were responsible' for engraving Michelangelo’s compositions after his drawings. He argues that they were 'well known and accessible, either directly or indirectly through reasonably accurate copies'. Bury believes that the first engraved version of Il Sogno, published by Michele Greco (or Lucchese) before 1545, was made by an anonymous printmaker. He also considers the present version, until recently attributed to Nicolas Beatrizet, as the work of an anonymous engraver, active in the circle of the publisher Antonio Salamanca whose address was added to the plate in the second state. Both engraved versions show some additional elements in the foreground not present in Michelangelo’s drawing, indicating that either one was derived from the other or that both are based on a slightly altered, now lost copy of the original composition.
See M. Bury, Michelangelo's Dream and Prints, in S. Buck, Michelangelo's Dream, 2010, London, p. 66-73 and 167-70, cat. 14.
In the catalogue of the Davidsohn sale, the present impression was erroneously catalogued as a first state, before all addresses.
Related Articles
Sorry, we are unable to display this content. Please check your connection.
The Dream (Il Sogno)ANONYMOUS 16TH CENTURY (FORMERLY ATTRIBUTED TO NICOLAS BEATRIZET) AFTER MICHELANGELO BUONARROTI (1475-1564)Estimate: GBP 1,500 - 2,500
You have agreed to be bound by the Conditions of Sale and if your bid is successful, you are legally obliged to pay for the lot you have won. The purchase price for a successful bid will be the sum of your final bid plus a buyer’s premium, any applicable taxes and any artist resale royalty, exclusive of shipping-related expenses.
Condition report
A Christie's specialist may contact you to discuss this lot or to notify you if the condition changes prior to the sale.
The condition of lots can vary widely and the nature of the lots sold means that they are unlikely to be in a perfect condition. Lots are sold in the condition they are in at the time of sale.
In addition to the catalogue description: - trimmed to the platermark below, to or just within the borderline above, narrow margins elsewhere. - the address of the publisher rubbed out. - a central horizontal crease, partially split and repaired in places (mostly from the right edge, approx. 70 mm. and a few much shorter splits in the centre, as on the dreamer's shoulder), another short skilfully repaired split to the right of the box. - an irrgular crease below the box, probably split and very skilfully repaired (approx. 70 mm.) - a couple of thin spots (one associated with the pulbisher's address rubbed out). - a small circular rubbed area in the right margin. - a small hole at the lower right corner. - some very pale foxmarks in places, mostly visible verso and in backlight. - remains of old tape and adhesive hinges at the left and right sheet edges verso, hinged at the left sheet edge verso. Otherwise as described and generally in good condition.
Cost calculator
Lot 8Sale 20187
The Dream (Il Sogno)ANONYMOUS 16TH CENTURY (FORMERLY ATTRIBUTED TO NICOLAS BEATRIZET) AFTER MICHELANGELO BUONARROTI (1475-1564)Estimate: GBP 1,500 - 2,500
Enter your bid amount for an estimated cost
Bid amount
Please enter numbers onlyAmount must be higher than the starting bidAmount must be higher than the current bid
Buyer's premium
Loss, damage and liability
Shipping
Estimated Excise Duty
Artist Resale Royalty
Estimated total cost exclusive of customs duties/charges and tariffs