'What is logically simple is so difficult mathematically'
Albert Einstein (1879-1955). Autograph letter signed (‘A.E.’) to Michele Besso, [Princeton], 16 August 1949.
In German, two pages, 278 x 218mm. Envelope.
Please note this lot is the property of a private consignor.
Published in Pierre Speziali (ed.) Albert Einstein. Michele Besso. Correspondance 1903-1955. Paris: Hermann, 1972. No. 161
This lot ships from Switzerland.
For international shipment (including the EU), buyers should take into account customs and duty clearance time when making purchases. As such procedures vary by country, and given the increased volume of deliveries at this time of year, Christie's recommends that purchases be completed as soon as possible. To ensure despatch of purchased lots before Christmas, full, cleared payment must be made by Monday, 11 December.
Please note this lot is the property of a private individual.
The condition of lots can vary widely and the nature of the lots sold means that they are unlikely to be in a perfect condition. Lots are sold in the condition they are in at the time of sale.
In our opinion there are no significant condition issues.
Additional Charge Details
Additional charges, including buyer’s premium, value added, sales or compensating use or equivalent tax, any and all shipping expenses, including costs, packing and handling, any loss/damage liability fees, customs duty, import tax, any local clearance fees applicable for your country, and all other applicable charges will apply.
In addition to the hammer price, the buyer agrees to pay to us the buyer’s premium together with any applicable VAT, sales, compensating use or equivalent tax in the place of sale. Please refer to our Conditions of Sale for further details on buyer's premium.
VAT: All lots shall be sold as part of the Margin Scheme unless stated with the Dagger symbol (†) or the words “Dagger Lot”, the Omega symbol (Ω) or the words “Omega Lot”, the Star symbol (*) or the words “Starred Lot” or with the Theta symbol (θ) or the words "Zero-rated Lot." Please refer to our Conditions of Sale for further information on VAT symbols.
You are responsible for any VAT (including any Import VAT) payable as a result of the sale of the lot. VAT charges and refunds depend on the particular circumstances of the buyer. In all circumstances EU and UK law takes precedence. For the purposes of this online-only auction, the VAT amount in the buyer’s premium for EU private buyers cannot be refunded. For buyers outside the EU, VAT may be refunded if certain conditions are met including showing proof of a ‘controlled’ export outside the EU within 30 days of shipment (for lots marked with the Star symbol (*) or the words “Starred Lot”, or with the Omega symbol (Ω) or the words “Omega Lot”, on Temporary Admission) and for all other lots proof of export within 3 months of shipping. For buyers outside the EU where items are shipped outside the EU through Christie’s Art Transport, you will not be required to pay the VAT at settlement. Please contact Christie’s Client Services on +44 (0) 207 839 9060 or by email at firstname.lastname@example.org for further information.
For details on private and company bidding registration, tax information (including refunds and exemptions), and CITES lots, please see our FAQs and Conditions of Sale or contact us by email at email@example.com or by telephone on +44 (0) 20 7839 9060.
You must pay the full amount due (comprising the hammer price, buyer’s premium, any applicable value added, sales, compensating use or equivalent tax, any and all shipping expenses, including costs, packing and handling, any loss/damage liability fees and all other applicable charges) no later than 23:59 (GMT) on Monday, 11 December 2017. This applies even if you wish to export the lot and an export license is, or may be, required. You will not acquire title and own the lot until all amounts due to Christie’s have been received by Christie’s in full and funds cleared.
Provided that your purchased lots are paid for in full and funds cleared by the payment deadline, Christie’s will store your purchased lots free of charge until the relevant deadline for shipment, at which time purchases will be shipped to you at your expense and pursuant to the instructions you provided at the time of payment. You must indicate if you wish to have your purchases shipped domestically or internationally at the time of checkout. Payment for your purchase, including any applicable charges for shipping, and a provision of your final shipping destination, must be returned to Christie’s by the payment deadline to qualify for this extended free-of-charge storage. If shipping arrangements have not been confirmed for any items sold or such items have not been paid for in full, and funds cleared by the payment deadline, administration and handling fees may be charged at Christie’s full discretion. If such shipments can be facilitated, purchases will be shipped to the address you provide at checkout. Purchases cannot be delivered to P.O. boxes. Please ask for details from your customs agent, applicable government entity or other organization.
If you opt to collect your purchase(s) at Christie's, 8 Place de la Taconnerie, 1204 Geneva, Switzerland, please kindly email Christie’s Client Service centre at firstname.lastname@example.org to schedule your collection at least 48 hours in advance and to secure any relevant forms. Payment must be made online prior to collection.
If you do not collect your purchase(s) within two weeks after sale close Christie’s reserves the right ship them to you at your expense.
Should you send someone to collect your purchase(s) on your behalf, please complete a Letter of Authorization and send it to us at email@example.com prior to collection. Your representative must present a valid picture ID at the time of collection, such as a driver’s license or passport.
'What is logically simple is so difficult mathematically': Einstein's generalised equations for gravitation.
Besso has asked Einstein to set out the generalised equations for gravitation which were the major preoccupation of Einstein's last years, and he complies with alacrity. 'You have expressed the wish that I should ride about a bit on my hobby horse for you ... I am persuaded that an essentially statistical theory, in spite of its great success, remains on the surface of things, and that one must ground oneself on the general relativity principle: generalisation of the gravitational equations for empty space'.
In this densely scientific manuscript, Einstein proceeds to walk Besso through the logic of these equations, which begin by replacing the symmetrical tensor gik with a non-symmetrical tensor: Einstein sets out the consequences in a series of equations, noting in passing the strains that the process places on the differential calculus involved, and interjecting in another place (perhaps with unintended irony), 'But it is not as simple as that'. He goes on: 'Now you will ask: did God whisper this in your ear? Unfortunately not. But the means is the following: there must be identities between the equations of the sort that they are compatible'. He explains the outlines of what he is looking for: 'These identities are the means for resolving the equations (but it doesn't happen "of its own accord")'.
He goes on: 'This is the framework of the thing': he will send Besso a paper which is about to be printed (Motion of particles in general relativity, 1949) which sets it all out. 'Whether there is anything true in the theory, I don't know, as I have been able to find no definitive solutions free of singularities. This is infamously difficult ...'. The letter concludes: 'The curse is that what is logically simple is so difficult mathematically'.
Need Help? Email our Specialists or call +1 212 636 2002 with questions.